User login
MILAN – according to Dee Anna Glaser, MD.
Speaking at the World Congress of Dermatology, Dr. Glaser, director of clinical research and interim chair of the department of dermatology at Saint Louis University, said that in her practice, acne and actinic keratosis are the most common medical indications for chemical peels and that “acne is just a winner all the way around.”
For acne, she added: “Chemical peels can help both the comedonal and the inflammatory component. It should probably be combined with other therapies, and it does produce both an exfoliative and an anti-inflammatory benefit,.”
A variety of chemical peel formulations can be considered for acne, Dr. Glaser noted. “Typically, you’re going to use a light chemical peel,” such as glycolic or salicylic acid. Other options include Jessner’s solution or a light trichloroacetic acid formulation, she said, adding that tretinoin alone can also be considered.
In choosing between glycolic and salicylic acid, Dr. Glaser said, “salicylic acid should theoretically be the best agent because it is lipophilic and the glycolic acid is hydrophilic.” The reality of how these agents perform clinically, though, may sort out differently.
Dr. Glaser pointed to a double-blind, randomized controlled trial of the two agents in 20 women with facial acne. The severity of participants’ inflammatory acne was mild to moderate, with an average of 27 inflammatory lesions, and they had been on a stable prescription or over-the-counter acne regimen for at least 2 months (Dermatol Surg. 2008 Jan;34[1]:45-50).
Patients received six peels – one every 2 weeks – with 30% glycolic acid (an alpha-hydroxy acid) and 30% salicylic acid (a beta-hydroxy acid) in the split-face study.
All participants started at 4 minutes of exposure and increased up to 5 minutes as tolerated, although timing is only really important for glycolic acid, the same duration of exposure was maintained for each agent for the sake of consistency between arms, said Dr. Glaser, one of the investigators.
Sharing photographs of study participants, she observed that after six peels, “there really isn’t a significant difference.” Therefore, she added, “even though salicylic acid should be better, you can see that glycolic acid really held its own in this study.”
Dr. Glaser pointed out that a trend was seen for slightly better results with salicylic acid and results with this agent were more durable than those seen with glycolic acid. Patients reported fewer side effects on the beta-hydroxy–treated side as well.
She referred to another study, conducted in Japan, that used a double-blind, split-face design to compare 40% glycolic acid with a placebo that had a similarly low pH of 2.0. The 26 patients with moderate acne received five peels on a biweekly schedule, with glycolic acid significantly outperforming placebo. Among acne subtypes, noninflammatory acne improved more than inflammatory acne with glycolic acid (Dermatol Surg. 2014 Mar;40[3]:314-22).
Dr. Glaser said that in her own practice, she still tries to use salicylic acid for her acne patients,” though some patients prefer the experience of a glycolic acid peel, with which there’s likely to be less pain. “So if you have a preference, or your patient has a preference, you will probably be able to use the acid that works best for you,” she said.
Whatever peel is chosen, it should be considered an adjuvant to other topical and systemic acne therapies, Dr. Glaser stressed. “To maintain the results, you really do need to maintain the patient on some sort of standard acne therapy that you would normally do.”
Peels can also be an effective part of a multipronged approach that includes laser therapy and intralesional steroids, she said. However, peels can be considered for monotherapy in patients who don’t tolerate other acne therapies, and they can be used safely in pregnancy, she said.
As with all such treatments, dermatologists should remember to consider and counsel about herpes simplex virus prophylaxis and sun protection.
Dr. Glaser reported financial relationships with Galderma, Ulthera, Ortho, Allergan, Cellgene, and other pharmaceutical companies.
MILAN – according to Dee Anna Glaser, MD.
Speaking at the World Congress of Dermatology, Dr. Glaser, director of clinical research and interim chair of the department of dermatology at Saint Louis University, said that in her practice, acne and actinic keratosis are the most common medical indications for chemical peels and that “acne is just a winner all the way around.”
For acne, she added: “Chemical peels can help both the comedonal and the inflammatory component. It should probably be combined with other therapies, and it does produce both an exfoliative and an anti-inflammatory benefit,.”
A variety of chemical peel formulations can be considered for acne, Dr. Glaser noted. “Typically, you’re going to use a light chemical peel,” such as glycolic or salicylic acid. Other options include Jessner’s solution or a light trichloroacetic acid formulation, she said, adding that tretinoin alone can also be considered.
In choosing between glycolic and salicylic acid, Dr. Glaser said, “salicylic acid should theoretically be the best agent because it is lipophilic and the glycolic acid is hydrophilic.” The reality of how these agents perform clinically, though, may sort out differently.
Dr. Glaser pointed to a double-blind, randomized controlled trial of the two agents in 20 women with facial acne. The severity of participants’ inflammatory acne was mild to moderate, with an average of 27 inflammatory lesions, and they had been on a stable prescription or over-the-counter acne regimen for at least 2 months (Dermatol Surg. 2008 Jan;34[1]:45-50).
Patients received six peels – one every 2 weeks – with 30% glycolic acid (an alpha-hydroxy acid) and 30% salicylic acid (a beta-hydroxy acid) in the split-face study.
All participants started at 4 minutes of exposure and increased up to 5 minutes as tolerated, although timing is only really important for glycolic acid, the same duration of exposure was maintained for each agent for the sake of consistency between arms, said Dr. Glaser, one of the investigators.
Sharing photographs of study participants, she observed that after six peels, “there really isn’t a significant difference.” Therefore, she added, “even though salicylic acid should be better, you can see that glycolic acid really held its own in this study.”
Dr. Glaser pointed out that a trend was seen for slightly better results with salicylic acid and results with this agent were more durable than those seen with glycolic acid. Patients reported fewer side effects on the beta-hydroxy–treated side as well.
She referred to another study, conducted in Japan, that used a double-blind, split-face design to compare 40% glycolic acid with a placebo that had a similarly low pH of 2.0. The 26 patients with moderate acne received five peels on a biweekly schedule, with glycolic acid significantly outperforming placebo. Among acne subtypes, noninflammatory acne improved more than inflammatory acne with glycolic acid (Dermatol Surg. 2014 Mar;40[3]:314-22).
Dr. Glaser said that in her own practice, she still tries to use salicylic acid for her acne patients,” though some patients prefer the experience of a glycolic acid peel, with which there’s likely to be less pain. “So if you have a preference, or your patient has a preference, you will probably be able to use the acid that works best for you,” she said.
Whatever peel is chosen, it should be considered an adjuvant to other topical and systemic acne therapies, Dr. Glaser stressed. “To maintain the results, you really do need to maintain the patient on some sort of standard acne therapy that you would normally do.”
Peels can also be an effective part of a multipronged approach that includes laser therapy and intralesional steroids, she said. However, peels can be considered for monotherapy in patients who don’t tolerate other acne therapies, and they can be used safely in pregnancy, she said.
As with all such treatments, dermatologists should remember to consider and counsel about herpes simplex virus prophylaxis and sun protection.
Dr. Glaser reported financial relationships with Galderma, Ulthera, Ortho, Allergan, Cellgene, and other pharmaceutical companies.
MILAN – according to Dee Anna Glaser, MD.
Speaking at the World Congress of Dermatology, Dr. Glaser, director of clinical research and interim chair of the department of dermatology at Saint Louis University, said that in her practice, acne and actinic keratosis are the most common medical indications for chemical peels and that “acne is just a winner all the way around.”
For acne, she added: “Chemical peels can help both the comedonal and the inflammatory component. It should probably be combined with other therapies, and it does produce both an exfoliative and an anti-inflammatory benefit,.”
A variety of chemical peel formulations can be considered for acne, Dr. Glaser noted. “Typically, you’re going to use a light chemical peel,” such as glycolic or salicylic acid. Other options include Jessner’s solution or a light trichloroacetic acid formulation, she said, adding that tretinoin alone can also be considered.
In choosing between glycolic and salicylic acid, Dr. Glaser said, “salicylic acid should theoretically be the best agent because it is lipophilic and the glycolic acid is hydrophilic.” The reality of how these agents perform clinically, though, may sort out differently.
Dr. Glaser pointed to a double-blind, randomized controlled trial of the two agents in 20 women with facial acne. The severity of participants’ inflammatory acne was mild to moderate, with an average of 27 inflammatory lesions, and they had been on a stable prescription or over-the-counter acne regimen for at least 2 months (Dermatol Surg. 2008 Jan;34[1]:45-50).
Patients received six peels – one every 2 weeks – with 30% glycolic acid (an alpha-hydroxy acid) and 30% salicylic acid (a beta-hydroxy acid) in the split-face study.
All participants started at 4 minutes of exposure and increased up to 5 minutes as tolerated, although timing is only really important for glycolic acid, the same duration of exposure was maintained for each agent for the sake of consistency between arms, said Dr. Glaser, one of the investigators.
Sharing photographs of study participants, she observed that after six peels, “there really isn’t a significant difference.” Therefore, she added, “even though salicylic acid should be better, you can see that glycolic acid really held its own in this study.”
Dr. Glaser pointed out that a trend was seen for slightly better results with salicylic acid and results with this agent were more durable than those seen with glycolic acid. Patients reported fewer side effects on the beta-hydroxy–treated side as well.
She referred to another study, conducted in Japan, that used a double-blind, split-face design to compare 40% glycolic acid with a placebo that had a similarly low pH of 2.0. The 26 patients with moderate acne received five peels on a biweekly schedule, with glycolic acid significantly outperforming placebo. Among acne subtypes, noninflammatory acne improved more than inflammatory acne with glycolic acid (Dermatol Surg. 2014 Mar;40[3]:314-22).
Dr. Glaser said that in her own practice, she still tries to use salicylic acid for her acne patients,” though some patients prefer the experience of a glycolic acid peel, with which there’s likely to be less pain. “So if you have a preference, or your patient has a preference, you will probably be able to use the acid that works best for you,” she said.
Whatever peel is chosen, it should be considered an adjuvant to other topical and systemic acne therapies, Dr. Glaser stressed. “To maintain the results, you really do need to maintain the patient on some sort of standard acne therapy that you would normally do.”
Peels can also be an effective part of a multipronged approach that includes laser therapy and intralesional steroids, she said. However, peels can be considered for monotherapy in patients who don’t tolerate other acne therapies, and they can be used safely in pregnancy, she said.
As with all such treatments, dermatologists should remember to consider and counsel about herpes simplex virus prophylaxis and sun protection.
Dr. Glaser reported financial relationships with Galderma, Ulthera, Ortho, Allergan, Cellgene, and other pharmaceutical companies.
EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM WCD2019